Haproxy vs kong. 6, while Kong is ranked #5 with an average rating of 6.
Haproxy vs kong 基于OpenResty的api网关项目kong的学习曲线有些陡峭，如果要自主修改增删，至少需要掌握：nginx、nginx模块开发、lua语言、openresty中的多个模块，然后是kong。 Kong vs Tyk; Think Twice When Evaluating Tyk. 2nd service consumes more load compare with others, the kong will manages load or not. Istio and other solutions. More posts you may like. 6. NGINX is a great open source web server, we all know that. Users say that Traefik's Ease of Use is rated at 8. ai（支流科技）创始人 & CTO， Apache APISIX PMC 王院生在活动上做了《有了 NGINX 和 Kong ，为什么还需要 Apache APISIX》的分享，以下是现场分享的文字版。 以下分享仅 Apache APISIX 和 Kong 都是开源的 微服务 API 网关 ，那么在这两者之间，如何去做比较和选择呢？. Subscribe to our blog. Tried a haproxy-web interface (haproxy-wi) on debian and get a lot of white pages, no time to troubleshoot this so it seems to make it even more complex. A side-by-side analysis of the security functions provided by Traefik and HAProxy highlights a robust security system in both. Background. 1:80 default_backend load_balancing Haproxy: I understand the concept but am under the impression that the configuration complexity goes way above my needs. I've been setting up Let's Encrypt SSL certificates via the nginx gui as well as set up proxy hosts. HAProxy is a tool in the Load Balancer / Reverse Proxy category of a tech stack. 1, which some find less intuitive than HAProxy's Envoy vs Kong Mesh. 支持心跳检测 Ng Unlike other ingress solutions discussed above, Kong focuses on decreasing privilege escalation by limiting the controller functionality to a single namespace. What API Gateway to choose: Kong, Gravitee, Tyk or HAProxy? API Gateways are more and more used nowadays: it permits you to have a single component to handle authentication and not code it several . 0 compared to Traefik's 8. Posted Jan 20, 2024 Updated Jan 21, 2024 . personally i want a controller with best traffic handling but i couldn't find any good article that test performance of controllers (i find one but it was in haproxy blog and as i expected it says haproxy is the best one) and if you see a good feature in one of them 一、HAProxy 简介. Compared 43% of the time. That's why today, we're zeroing in on one of the most Apache APISIX 和 Kong 都是开源的微服务 API 网关，那么在这两者之间，如何去做比较和选择呢？ 这两个项目都有完善的文档和测试来覆盖，也有不少的生产用户在使用，所以不用去担心稳定性和它们的可持续发展，本文会从功能和性能这两个最直接和可验证的角度去做下对 We use HAProxy as the ingress controller on our cluster as it was the only one I found at the time which had decent TCP support. HAProxy，全称为 High Availability Proxy，是一个专门用于负载均衡和高可用性的开源软件。自2000年首次发布以来，HAProxy 因其卓越的性能和稳定性，特别是在处理大规模的 TCP 和 HTTP 请求时，成 HAProxy vs Kong Mesh comparison. Just saying Kong is an API gateway, there is a difference between ingress controller and API gateway. 844,944 professionals have used our research since 2012. 2. The basic configuration of HAProxy is to be a load balancer. io has expired. Traefik vs. See all alternatives. The specific line we care about is option httpchk GET /checkout/v2/health HTTP/1. Kong API Gateway. Reviewers appreciate Kong's HAProxy or High Availability proxy is a load balancing solution that is well known for its high performance. Reviewers mention that HAProxy's extensive API support and integration capabilities make it easier to connect with various third-party services and tools. HAProxy, while also capable, has a slightly lower score in this area, suggesting it may require more manual configuration for integrations. HAProxy is ranked #3 with an average rating of 7. 2, while NGINX scores lower at 8. . NGINX next to HAProxy looks like a 2CV Load balancers feature comparison: Envoy vs HA Proxy vs Nginx. 0 to them, but load balancing is not one of those things. Monkeyanator Monkeyanator. Improve this answer. Hear what customers and industry analysts have to say about Kong. Reviewers mention that Azure Load Balancer's performance and reliability score of 9. Let's be real, navigating the kubernetes ecosystem can feel like you're threading a labyrinth. Envoy, HAProxy and others in Service Mesh. Voyager 是一个基于 HAProxy 的 HAProxy performs well in benchmarks compared to both Traefik and Nginx, and HAProxy supports more load-balancing algorithms than either of them. This is intentional and more can be read about it on the HAProxy mailing list. We have used some of these posts to build our list of alternatives and similar projects. NGINX vs. A Comparative Study of Emissary-ingress and Kong: Unveiling the Giants of API Gateways. Amazon EC2. HAProxy holds a 13. Wireguard on the vs had a throughput of 15MBit, on my current Kong: Kong is one of the most popular API gateway solutions built on top of OpenResty. The last one was on 2024-05-29. In addition to features of traditional API gateways, APISIX has the features of dynamic Haven't set up any load balancing unless it does so automatically. Tyk is an early-stage startup with limited ability to support enterprise scale. Base your decision on 2 verified peer reviews, ratings, pros & cons, pricing, support and more. Users on G2 appreciate HAProxy's extensive documentation and community support, which they find invaluable for troubleshooting and implementation. When comparing quality of ongoing product support, reviewers felt that HAProxy is the preferred option. Some tutorials I've seen manage nginx via ssh only so I'm not sure if I am losing some features by using the gui vs ssh. Isito is ranked #1 with an average rating of 8. ly/kong Comparar HAProxy e Kong API Gateway lado a lado em termos de preços, satisfação do usuário e recursos, usando dados de usuários reais. DOWNLOAD THE COMPLETE REPORT. 接下来我将从以下几个维度对 Apache APISIX Ingress 和 Traefik 进行一些对比，方便大家在选型时对产品有更多的认知。 协议支持 . You also saw how HAProxy load balancer works as an API gateway: managing routing, load balancing, rate limiting and other complexities. 0 与 Kong 3. Kong Konnect vs. It accomplishes this by monitoring the API of the underlying orchestration or registry HashiCorp Consul vs Kong Mesh. One wrong turn, and you're staring down a Minotaur of complexity. 6% mindshare in SM, compared to Kong’s 19. Kong 的插件机制是其高可扩展性的根源，Kong 可以很方便地为路由和服务提供各种插件，网关所需要的基本特性，Kong 都如数支持。 如果现有的插件不能满足你的，需求，你也可以使用 lua 语言轻松自己开发一个满足自己需求的插件。 11 Open Source solutions including NGINX, Traefik, Istio, HAProxy, Gloo, Ambassador, Skipper and others Users report that HAProxy excels in API / Integrations with a score of 9. Even though Kong is open source, KongHQ provides maintenance and support licenses for 它似乎也非常适合负载均衡 TCP 连接。这是官方的 HAProxy ingress，在生产环境使用的经验告诉我们它具有极其稳定的记录。如果需要，您还可以获得付费支持订阅。 5. So far, I've seen: - nginx-ingress - voyager - traefik - contour I've personally used traefik. By Dorian Beganovic 1 min read. Follow edited Oct 28, 2022 at 1:36. 支持TCP与Http协议，工作在网络4层和7层 2. Istio — Unlocking the Secrets to Mastering Kubernetes Ingress # istio # kubernetes # nginx # traefik. VMware Tanzu Platform vs Istio. i want to choose a controller and i want to know other's opinion. Meaning that you declare an endpoint in Kong that exposes data from one backend, and does the magic in the middle (authorization, limiting, etc). 0 的 QPS 都下降明显，但是 Kong 3. Kong Mesh vs Istio. Hands down. Kong安装. The first two are part of the Management block: the portal NGINX vs. В общем случае, возможно, не слишком влияет на то, как принимается и передается трафик, однако всегда полезно знать потенциальные нюансы и EOL dates on HAProxy website are formatted as YYYY-Qn, with YYYY being the year, and Qn the quarter of that year. Популярные — это nginx, traefik, haproxy, envoy. Cloudflare Application Security and Performance. Build vs Buy Kong vs Postman Kong vs MuleSoft HAProxy和Nginx都是比较优秀的reverse proxy(反向代理)，但它们之间的区别还是挺大的。本文对两者做一个简单的对比。 As Kubernetes has become the de facto orchestration platform for deploying cloud native applications, networking and traffic management have emerged as pivotal challenges when managing access to services and Kong 需要依赖于 PostgreSQL 或 Cassandra 数据库，这使 Kong 的整个架构非常臃肿，并且会给企业带来高可用的问题。如果数据库故障了，那么整个 API 网关都会出现故障。 Kong 的路由使用的是遍历查找，当网关内有超 概述. Additionally, 91% of HAProxy users are willing to recommend the 负载均衡器是数据中心的入口点，处于访问一切资源的关键路径上。这给了他们一些有趣的特征。首先，它们是在基础设施中需要监控的最重要的点。其次，他们处于 Cayent的Kubernetes顶级入口控制器比较 （19年9月） – Kong，Traefik，HAProxy，Istio Ingress，Nginx和大使的简短文本比较； Kubernetes入口控制器：如何选择合适的控制器：ITNEXT的第1部分 -Nginx入口控制器与AWS ALB入口控制器的相当深入的文字比较。 所以我们更偏重于开源的 API 网关方案，比如 Kong、APISIX 和 Tyk 等。这些 API 网关是从云原生软件基金会（CNCF）的全景图中摘选的： 对比选型的依据 部署和维护成本. which ingress controller do you prefer and why. It is implemented based on NGINX and etcd. fr. Both the API proxy and the API gateway sit in front of your existing APIs, acting like gatekeepers, but with a big difference in capabilities. Before comparing the two popular load balancers, let us discuss the need for a load balancer and its available options. Find out what your peers are saying about HAProxy vs. HAProxy vs VMware NSX. The richness and complexity of HAProxy make it less Kong is an open-source API gateway that is built on top of Nginx. Kong – separate API strategy for north/south vs. Whether they are solving north/south or east/west challenges, our customers tell us they want a consistent implementation using Envoy Proxy. 目录. Compared 5% of the time. Google Compute Engine HAProxy (High Availability Proxy) is a free, very fast and reliable solution offering high availability, load balancing, and proxying for TCP and HTTP-based applications. Kong is basically an Nginx proxy that adds a lot of functionality on top of it using Lua. Related Topics Programming comments sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment. Updated: March 2025. Posts with mentions or reviews of haproxy. 0 的 10 轮 QPS 通过探索 HAProxy、NGINX、Kong 和 Kubernetes 等流行的解决方案，您可以做出明智的决定，并为您的网络应用找到完美的工具。 不要让不确定性束缚您的手脚--现在就拥抱这些前沿解决方案，提升您的网络架构！ 2021 年 5 月， 云原生社区 技术沙龙·广州站，API7. Buyer's Guide. Reviewers felt that HAProxy meets the needs of their business better than Istio. Compare HAProxy Enterprise vs. ) This will proactively check for a 200 status code, and will mark the backend down immediately if the request fails. But I think after 15 years in this industry I can justify voicing an honest opinion. The pros and cons of 4 API Gateways: Kong, Gravitee, Tyk and, HAProxy. The system is more complex than Kong: it depends on 3 apps. However, we’ll explore a few areas 从上述对比图中可以看到，在启用「限制请求数量类」的插件后，APISIX 3. Traefik using this comparison chart. Compared 5% 再比如传统的HAProxy就是Proxy，Nginx就偏Gateway。 这个概念和数据通信网络的Core Router和Edge/Service Router是差不多的，Edge Router是感知服务的，理论上功能更多，Data Plane基本一样，Control Plane功能更丰富而已。 Kong/OpenResty：Nginx性能没的说，Lua动态没得说，Kong增加了 HAProxy跟LVS类似，本身就只是一款负载均衡软件；单纯从效率上来讲HAProxy会比Nginx有更出色的负载均衡速度，在并发处理上也是优于Nginx的。 HAProxy支持TCP协议的负载均衡转发，可以对MySQL读进行负载均衡，对后端的MySQL节点进行检测和负载均衡，大家可以 Kong插件拦截请求、响应，类似于Java Servlet中的拦截器，实现请求、响应的AOP处理。 市场上较为成熟的软件负载均衡解决方案为Nginx、HAProxy和LVS；硬件负载均衡解决方案为F5、A10等。 软硬件负载均衡解决 从中我们可以看出，Kong 和 APISIX 都是非常好的选择。 如果你有其他推荐的 API 网关，或者有更多的观点，欢迎留言。 本文参与 腾讯云自媒体同步曝光计划 ，分享自微信公众号。 Vergleichen Sie HAProxy und Kong API Gateway direkt gegenüber in Bezug auf Preis, Benutzerzufriedenheit und Funktionen, basierend auf Daten von echten Benutzern. 支持通过URL健康检测 4. HAProxy or High Availability proxy is a load Kong. For feature updates and roadmaps, our reviewers preferred the direction of HAProxy over Istio. padok. 8% mindshare. r/programming • Crafting a Clean, Maintainable, and Understandable Makefile for a C Project. DOWNLOAD NOW. Apache APISIX is a cloud-native, high-performance, scalable API gateway. Limitations and Potential Issues. if you only need to load balance + HA some third web server then haproxy is enough. HAProxy Ingress. ) which is a very popular open source HTTP proxy server. 7, while HAProxy's logging features are rated lower at 8. However, minor differences do exist. 是可以在单机就能完整部署，还是需要多个节点配合才能使用？ 是否有外部的数据库依赖？ One difference I’m aware of, is that haproxy and nginx ingresses can work in TCP mode, whereas traefik only works in HTTP/HTTPS modes. east/west traffic Our customers may need either API gateway technology or service mesh and sometimes both. 0 的 QPS 下降幅度更大。 APISIX 3. Please share your experiences using HAProxy as an API gateway in the section below! Contact us to learn more about HAProxy Enterprise or sign up for a free trial. Everything else I was finding only talked about HTTP and I was looking to implement a HA SFTP service. To learn more, read our detailed Service Mesh Report (Updated: February 2025). 2k次，点赞8次，收藏17次。**Kong Gateway** 和 **Apache APISIX** 专注于 API 管理和网关场景，提供了丰富的特性和服务扩展性；- **社区与生态系统**：Traefik 社区快速发展，拥有广泛的用户群，特别是在云原生社区中非常受欢迎，有强大的社区支持和更新活跃。 APISIX Ingress vs Traefik . Reviewers also preferred doing business with HAProxy overall. 1\r\nHost:\ haproxy. Compare HAProxy and Kong Konnect head-to-head across pricing, user satisfaction, and features, using data from actual users. HAProxy: Key Similarities and Differences. 作为网关，最为核心的能力便是要能够正确的代理流量。 HAProxy vs. Compare price, features, and reviews of the software side-by-side to make the best HAProxy: Community-driven HAProxy Ingress Controller as well as enterprise offering from HAProxy Tech; Istio: Ingress Gateway for Istio-enabled clusters I am confusing about kong api gateway and Haproxy/F5 load balancer. Service Mesh. Gravitee is an Open-source API Gateway developed using Java by Gravitee Source since January 2015. Haproxy 是目前比较流行的一种集群调度工具，同类集群调度器工具有很多，如 LVS 和 Nginx。相比较而言，LVS 性能最好，但是搭建相对复杂；Nginx 的 upstream 模块虽然支持集群功能，但是对集群节点健康检查功能不强，性能没有 Haproxy 好。 Traefik vs HAProxy: A Security Showdown. If you want to ingress services like SMTP or MQTT, then this is a useful distinction. answered Mar 14, 2019 at 18:13. When it comes to reverse proxying and load balancing, there are more similarities than differences between NGINX and HAProxy. 对于做软负载，主流的方案有LVS、Haproxy、Nginx？对于Haproxy和Nginx，我们如何选择呢？回答这个问题之前，我根据个人使用经验来讲下它们的特点！ Haproxy特点 1. Download the complete report. We've been using ingress-nginx and haproxy-ingress for a while. Baseline of features is fron Nginx here. Voyager. 0 的 10 轮 QPS 的平均值是 9154，Kong 3. 集群中的服务该如何供集群外访问？K8S提供了ingress特性，而可实现ingress的软件有nginx、haproxy、traefix等，本文描述如何将API网关服务Kong作为ingress来暴露集群提供的服务。. It provides various features like routing, security, analytics, and transformations. Christian Matthew. Don't pay for In this article, we will test five different popular load balancers: NGINX, HAProxy, Envoy, Traefik, and Amazon Application Load Balancer Users say that Kong API Gateway offers superior logging and reporting capabilities with a score of 8. If you are the owner, log in to Cloudflare for domain renewal options. Also, haproxy supports the “PROXY” protocol, allowing you to pass real client IP to backend services. Kong is an open source API gateway that is build on top of (NGINX. It provides strong support for microservices and integrates with Docker, Kubernetes, Rancher, and Consul. Fargate vs ECS AWS Container Services. Traefik requires minimal configuration and uses automated service discovery to inject routes to backend services. NGINX 和 HAProxy 均基于纯软且采用事件驱动型架构。尽管 HAProxy MP 的性能优于 HAProxy MT，但由于无法在各个进程之间共享状态，因此管理变得更加复杂，详见上文HAProxy：配置和版本控制一节。HAProxy Haproxy is a "load balancer" it doesn't know to serve files or dynamic content. 1,416 2 2 gold badges 15 15 silver badges 30 30 bronze badges. if you need to implement some static content or some logic in routing of the requests before terminating them on a third server then you may 文章浏览阅读2. This line tells HAProxy to call our backend with a request to /checkout/v2/health (with the request host as “haproxy”. HAProxy vs Istio. Isito and Kong are both solutions in the Service Mesh category. HAProxy and Nginx server are a few services that are used by most high profile companies to conduct load balancing. 支持Session共享、Cookies引导 3. Base your decision on 3 verified peer reviews, ratings, pros & cons, pricing, support and more. * What API Gateway to choose: Kong, Gravitee, Tyk or HAProxy? Don't take our word for it. nginx is a web server capable of many interesting things. Its primary purpose is to manage and secure APIs. Nginx; Share. Reviewers mention that HAProxy shines in Quality of Support, scoring 9. VMware NSX Alternatives. 目录; 说明; 代理服务软件对比：haproxy、nginx、envoy; 开源API网关项目对比; 参考; 说明. Nginx is a web server but also acts as a load balancer and plays a key role in improving performance. HAProxy and Kong are both solutions in the Service Mesh category. The 在这样的背景下，以 Apache APISIX 和 Kong 等为代表的云原生 API 网关项目得到了越来越多开发者的青睐。 Apache APISIX 是一个云原生、高性能、可扩展的 API 网关，由深圳支流科技捐赠给 Apache 基金会，并于 Kong. When assessing the two solutions, reviewers found HAProxy easier to use, set up, and administer. Will kong api gateway handle the load balancing also! My scenario is, if i have 5 micro-services on kong. Kong API Gateway (260) 在500 RPS时，我们开始看到HAProxy的更大的延迟峰值，持续时间和延迟都增加，延迟峰值长达10秒，这些延迟峰值可以持续几秒钟。 在这种情况下，NGINX的性能明显优于HAProxy，其延迟峰值大约在1秒左右，并且持 随着微服务的兴起，网关已成为最重要的一个部分。众多的 Api 网关的产生，使不少人面临着 2 个比较尖锐的问题。一个是增加了面试的难度，另外一个是选择一个最适合自己的网关并非易事。 基于此，我简单的比较了 4 种 API 网关：Kong，Gravitee，Tyk和HAProxy。 Nginx其实基于server的功能来说，是Haproxy不具备的，让Haproxy像一个普通Web server那样回复一个普通的HTTP请求是很难的，不大规模修改源码根本做不到。Haproxy是围绕转发模型设计的，整个流程就是围绕如何快速把一个请求或者回复转发到另一端。 Istio vs Kong Mesh comparison. Although HAproxy supports various load balancing algorithms, configuring them requires a trained workforce to handle Kong is able to secure your microservices and do other nifty things, such as rate limiting and applying OAuth2. We've been testing out Contour Ingress as a replacement. 0. Go to Cloudflare Dashboard Compare NGINX Plus vs Kong vs HAProxy Enterprise Edition in Load Balancing Software category based on 439 reviews and features, pricing, support and more Traefik is a modern, cloud-native HTTP reverse proxy and load balancer. 4,389 5 5 gold badges 37 37 silver badges 47 47 bronze badges. 2d2d. NGINX Service-Mesh vs Istio. When using Kong your endpoints have a 1:1 relationship with your backends. 3, while Kong is ranked #4 with an average rating of 6. 支持8种负载均衡策略 5. 6, while Kong is ranked #5 with an average rating of 6. 6 is a standout feature, indicating that it consistently delivers high uptime and low latency. It provides features like rate limiting, authentication, and analytics to manage API proxy vs API gateway. This page takes a conservative approach, using the start of quarter as the EOL date (YYYY-01-01 for Q1, YYYY-04-01 for Q2, YYYY-07-01 for Q3, YYYY-10-01 HAProxy beats NGINX. We’ll define the frontend and backend for the example: frontend haproxy_as_api_gateway bind 127. 1. February 2025. Both work pretty well, but lack a few things we want. 注意：本文采用Helm方式安装，否则可用原始YAMLs文件方式安装，如： # db is pgsql % kubectl apply -f https://bit. March 2025. Compared 6% of the time. 这两个项目都有完善的文档和测试来覆盖，也有不少的生产用户在使用，所以不用去担心稳定性和它们的可持续发展，本文会从功能和性 Kong Ingress; Traefik Ingress; HAProxy Ingress; Istio Ingress; APISIX Ingress; 除了上面列举的这些，还有非常多的Ingress Controller，面对如此多的Ingress Controller，我们该如何选择呢？ HAProxy还支持完全自定义配置文件模 hey guys. Features Nginx HA Proxy Envoy; Load balancer + + + HTTP/TCP/UDP support Just wondering what ingress controller are you guys using and why. To learn more, read our detailed Service Mesh Report (Updated: March 2025). Compared 33% of the time. yjnejkjtzkajkbnztvimrffysuuwcrpidqfgwpcnigibsuwwoscvtlorncndfbastywezaimxtjfa
